Today you might come across lots of options in the market regarding the food dehydrators. It becomes quite difficult to choose the best product among them after making a good comparison. If you do not compare the two different branded food dehydrators then, you can regret about your buying decision later.
We are sure that you might have heard about the STX food dehydrators and the Excalibur food dehydrators. Thus, in the below article also, we will discuss and compare these two robust and high-quality food dehydrators.
We will try to provide you every bit of relevant information regarding the STX dehydrator vs. Excalibur so that you can make your buying decision wisely.
So, let’s continue reading!
Brief Introduction About Excalibur Company and the STX International Company
Well! Excalibur Company established in the year 1973, and the company’s headquarters located in Sacramento, CA. From past 40 years, this company is in the manufacturing business. There are lots of famous chefs who use and endorse for food drying purposes. In the year 2011, Excalibur was bought by The Legacy Cos of a Florida that manufactures the commercial food equipment as well as marketing appliances. The Excalibur brand is very prevalent over the internet also. Its robust construction and unique airflow technology make it different from any other competing company’s food dehydrator.
On the other hand, the STX international is also a food dehydrator manufacturing company. It mainly deals in the commercial food dehydrators. The construction of the food dehydrators done after keeping in mind the commercial use of the appliances. It mostly uses in big hotels or restaurants. The farms which need a food dehydrator for daily drying usually prefer to buy the STX food dehydrator.
Let’s read about the comparison between these two!
Comparison Chart of Popular STX Food Dehydrator Vs. Excalibur Food Dehydrator
Popular STX Food Dehydrator
| Serial No | Product Name | Product Dimension (inches) | Product Weight (lbs) | No.of trays | Temperature range | Drying space | Fan size | Wattage | Timer | Editor rating | Where to Buy? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | STX INTERNATIONAL Dehydra STX-DEH-1200W-XLS | 17.25 x 20.5 x 15.6 in | 38.5 pounds | 10 | 95 degrees F to 155 Degrees F | 16 Square Feet | 7 inches | 1200 watts | 15 hours | 4.2/5 | Check on Amazon |
| 2 | STX International STX-DEH-600W-SST Dehydra | 12.5 x 19 x 13.75 in | 22.5 pounds | 10 | 85 degrees F to 155 degrees Fahrenheit | 11.8 Square Feet | 5.5 Inch | 600 watts | 40 hour | 3.1/5 | Check on Amazon |
| 3 | STX International STX-DEH-600W-SST-CB Stainless Steel | 12.5 x 13.8 x 19 inches | 22.5 pounds | 10 | 85 degrees F to 155 Degrees F | 1055 Cubic Inches | NA | 600 watts | 40 hour | 4.3/5 | Check on Amazon |
Popular Excalibur Food Dehydrator
| Serial No | Product Name | Product Dimension (inches) | Product Weight (lbs) | Number of Trays | Temperature Range (°F) | Drying Space Area (sq ft) | Fan Size (inch) | Wattage (Watt) | Timer | Editor rating | Where to Buy? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Excalibur 3926TB | 17 x 19 x 12.5 in | 22 lbs | 9 | 105 to 165 | 15 | 7-inch | 600 | Yes; 26 hour | 4.7/5 | Check on Amazon |
| 2 | Excalibur 3900B 9 Tray Deluxe | 17 x 19 x 12.5 in | 22 lbs | 9 | 105 to 165 | 15 | 7-inch | 600 | No | 4.7/5 | Check on Amazon |
| 3 | Excalibur 2900ECB 9-Tray Economy | 17 x 19 x 12.5 in | 22 lbs | 9 | 105 to 165 | 15 | 7-inch | 440 | No | 4.6/5 | Check on Amazon |
| 4 | Excalibur 3526TB 5 Tray Dehydrator | 17 x 19 x 8.5 in | 15 lbs | 5 | 105 to 165 | 8 | 5-inch | 400 | Yes; 26 hour | 4.4./5 | Check on Amazon |
| 5 | Excalibur 3500B 5 Tray Deluxe Dehydrator | 19 x 17 x 8.5 in | 15 lbs | 5 | 105 to 165 | 8 | 5-inch | 440 | No | 4.5/5 | Check on Amazon |
Comparison Between STX Food Dehydrator Vs. Excalibur Food Dehydrator
There are lots of things which differentiate the STX dehydrator with the Excalibur. Some of them are as follows along with our feedback:
1. Drying Space of the Dehydrators
The first criteria which we have chosen for comparing the STX dehydrator with the Excalibur are the capacity of the appliances. The drying space or capacity only calculates the number of trays with which the dehydrator comes.
- Excalibur food dehydratorThe drying space in most of the Excalibur dehydrators is between 8 feet to 15 feet depending on the number of trays. Every dehydrator’s tray provides around 225 square inches of drying space.
- STX food dehydratorNow, the STX food dehydrator, you get the drying space between 11 square feet to 16 square feet. It mostly comes with the ten drying trays.
Our Feedback
The more drying space you have, the more amounts of foods can get dry in one single batch. So, if you have a small family then, you can buy the Excalibur food dehydrator. However, the Excalibur also comes with the large drying space. So, you can consider them also. If you have a big family and usually organize parties then, buying the STX food dehydrator is a better option.
2. Shape of the Trays
The form of the shelves also plays a significant role in the drying process. There are three kinds of shapes which the drying trays have, i.e., rounded, rectangular or square. The rectangular trays offer more space than the square ones. When you have square or rectangular shape trays in your appliance, it let you dry the longer strips of the food. In round shape trays, lots of drying space get wasted.
- STX food dehydratorThe STX food dehydrator has the rectangular shaped trays in which the fan locates on the back side
- Excalibur food dehydratorIn a maximum number of the Excalibur food dehydrators have square shaped trays. However, they also come with the rectangularly shaped trays also.
Our Feedback
In both the food dehydrators, the trays come in rectangular or square shape. So, we cannot say that which one is better as both of them are equal in this criterion.
3. Temperature Control Feature
It is imperative that the food dehydrator must come with the temperature control feature in it. It not only lets you dehydrate a range of different types of food, but you also get good drying results in the end. If the temperature of the dehydrator set at the lower range then, it can lead to the food’s fermentation or spoilage. On the other hand, if you choose too much high-temperature range then, it can destroy the health-promoting enzymes along with the useful nutrients of the raw foods.
- STX food dehydratorAll the STX food dehydrators come with the feature of the adjustable thermostat, i.e., between 95 to 155 Degrees.
- Excalibur food dehydratorMaximum number of Excalibur food dryers comes with the feature of the adjustable thermostat. But before buying, always read the product specifications.
Our Feedback
The STX food dehydrators offer you a slightly broader temperature range in comparison to the Excalibur food dehydrators.
4. Position of the Fan in the Dehydrator
The location of the fan decides that how uniformly your food will get dry in the food dehydrator. The fan mostly locates at the back, top or side of the food dehydrator. The fan which locates on the back side of the unit helps in the horizontal air flow so that the entire heat flows evenly all over the trays. With this feature, there is no need to rotate the trays of the appliance in between the process of the food dehydration. Additionally, there is one more significant benefit of rear located fan that you do not have to worry regarding the drippings from the fruits, vegetables, and meats over the fan at all.
- STX food dehydratorThe fan in the food dryer is located on the rear side to aid in the horizontal air flow.
- Excalibur food dehydratorThe Excalibur food dehydrators possess rear-mounted fans that move the heat uniformly on all the trays.
Our Feedback
Since both food dehydrators have rear mounted fans, we cannot differentiate between the two.
5. Warranty of the Products
The warranty is a significant feature of the dehydrators. It helps you in getting free-of-cost repairs or replacement of the product if something goes wrong with the machine.
- STX food dehydratorThe manufacturer of the STX offer warranty period between 1 to 3 years.
- Excalibur food dehydratorThe manufacturer of the STX offer warranty period up to five years.
Our Feedback
The manufacturer of the Excalibur food dehydrators offers a longer warranty on its products in comparison to the STX international food dehydrators. So, if you want to have more extended warranty product then, you should go for the Excalibur.
6. In-built Timer Feature
The inbuilt timer in the food dehydrator offers us lots of benefits. After setting the timer, you can do any work side-by-side. There is no need to check the status of the drying food in between the process. The machine will get automatically shut down as soon as the time of the gets up. It aids in even and impeccable drying of the raw food. People with the busy and hectic schedule prefer to buy the food dryer with the timer.
- STX food dehydratorThe STX food dehydrator also comes with a feature of a timer that you can preset up to the maximum of 40 hours.
- Excalibur food dehydratorIt is true that all the models of the Excalibur do not possess an integrated timer, but most of them do have an inbuilt timer that ranges between 26 to 99 hours.
Our Feedback
In comparison between the STX dehydrator vs. Excalibur, the Excalibur dehydrator’s timer offers you a longer maximum setting of the time.
7. Material Used in Manufacturing
Different types of material used in manufacturing the food dehydrators, for example, plastic or stainless steel. The machines made from the stainless steel material works for longer years. But the food dehydrators with the plastic body possess shorter life. In fact, the plastic made dryers are more susceptible to the breakage issues.
- STX food dehydratorSTX food dehydrator also comes with the stainless steel construction body that provides you longer service.
- Excalibur food dehydratorThe most of the Excalibur food dehydrator used the stainless steel material for manufacturing the appliances.
Our Feedback
Here also, both food dehydrators have the same kind of body construction. So, we cannot tell that which one has a better body.
8. Weight of the Appliance
The food dehydrator with the less weight is easier to move and carry from one place to another. If the machine is heavy then, it lacks the portability. People mostly prefer to buy lightweight food dryers for home and heavy weight for the commercial purposes. The reason behind the heavyweight of the appliance can be the stainless steel trays or stainless steel body also. The food dehydrators with the plastic body are lightweight to carry.
- STX food dehydratorThe weight of the STX food dehydrator usually fluctuates between 22 lbs. to 38 lbs.
- Excalibur food dehydratorThe weight of the Excalibur food dehydrators usually varies between 25 lbs. to 40 lbs.
Our Feedback
We think that the weight of both the food dehydrators is almost same. So, we cannot say that which one is lightweight and which one is heavyweight.
9. Wattage Power
The wattage power of the food dehydrators decides that how fast the drying of the food is going to get the finish. The food dehydrator with the high wattage power usually dries the food much more rapidly than the small wattage machines. But the high wattage also affects your monthly electricity bills to some extent. The foods like meat and jerky need more wattage power for drying, and delicate foods like herbs need less power for drying. The appliances with the high wattage take less time for drying in comparison to the low wattage machines.
- STX food dehydratorThe wattage power of the different STX food dehydrators ranges between 600 watts to 1200 watts. It can dehydrate a large variety of food quickly.
- Excalibur food dehydratorThe wattage power of the different STX food dehydrators ranges between 220 watts to 600 watts.
Our Feedback
If you want to have food dehydrator for the commercial use then, STX Food dehydrator is a good option. It has the more wattage power that results in the fast and the bulk drying quickly. But if you want to dehydrate food like herbs or spices more then, Excalibur dryer must be selected.
Video Guide
Conclusion
STX dehydrator vs. Excalibur: which one you think is suitable for you to buy? Well! There are lots of things which you have to consider while buying any food dehydrator like your requirements, budgets, needs, etc.
In the above article, we have reviewed and compared the STX food dehydrator with the Excalibur food dehydrator by different criteria like weight, drying space, wattage power, features and much more. We have tried to compare both the dehydrators one critical aspect.
So, now you have to decide that which food dehydrator accomplish well your needs. If you want a food dehydrator with the high power wattage then, STX is a good option. But if you need a food dehydrator with the compact size then, the Excalibur can fulfill your this requirement.
Both food dehydrators have their pros and cons in one or other way. Thus, we cannot say that which one is better for us. However, we are sure that whatever product you buy it will serve you for an extended period owing to its robust construction and good quality material.
In the end, we just want to say that if any one of you have bought the model of the STX food dehydrator or the Excalibur food dehydrator, do share your experiences with us. It will help us in making our article more informative to the dear readers like you. Besides this, if you have any query regarding the Excalibur vs. STX then, you can write to us. We will reply back to you at the earliest.
We own the STX dehydrator and it worked well for a few years. The electronics failed after a couple of years so now I have a large pile of junk. It was not worth saving a few bucks, go with something better made.
Thanks for sharing your views.